Short answer: Drive analysis measures the current harmonics reflected back to the grid by the frequency converter, the effect of the pulsed voltage sent to the motor on insulation and bearings, and the high-frequency leakage current flowing through ground, all in the same study. The aim is to find the cause of recurring drive failures, motor winding damage, and residual current device tripping, and to base potential investment decisions on these measurements.

Variable speed drives (VSDs), also known in the field as frequency converters, inverters, or VFDs, are power electronics converters that adjust the voltage and frequency of a single motor according to the torque-speed requirements of the load (Notification on Environmentally Friendly Design Requirements for Electric Motors and Variable Speed Drives, Article 5(1)(c)). Capacitor failures, motors with repeatedly burned windings, and unexplained residual current device trippings often point to the same source in our measurements: the drive.

Service note: AES Innovation performs the measurements and evaluations described on this page with its own engineers. Energy analysis, harmonic measurement, and compensation evaluation are outside the scope of our TÜRKAK accreditation; our accreditation scope includes periodic inspections of grounding, leakage current, switchboards, and thermography in low-voltage installations.

Grid side: harmonics, power factor, and DC bus.

Most drives have a six-pulse diode rectifier and a DC bus capacitor at their input; the rectifier draws current from the grid in pulses, not as a sine wave. The dominant (characteristic) harmonics of a three-phase rectifier with a pulse count of p are on the order of p·n ± 1; in a six-pulse drive, these are the 5th, 7th, 11th, 13th, and so on. IEEE 519-2014 also links the dominant harmonics to the pulse count (clause 5.5). In practice, the 5th and 7th harmonics are more prominent; their amplitudes vary depending on whether there is a DC choke or input reactor, the transformer power, and the load ratio.

The power factor is also misleading. Since the fundamental component of the current is almost in phase with the voltage, the cos φ (displacement power factor) shown by the compensation relay is usually high; however, since harmonic currents amplify the apparent power, the actual power factor (λ = P/S) is lower. The capacitor does not correct the harmonic component.

Harmonics create additional losses in transformers and cables, but the main risk is often in the compensation panel. IEC 61921 states that the lifespan of a capacitor bank connected to a harmonic network may be shortened and that harmonic amplitudes will generally increase unless a suitable detuning reactor is installed in series with each stage (IEC 61921:2017, clauses 6.3.1.1 and 6.3.2.1).

A common mistake is comparing the current THD (total harmonic distortion) measured at the drive input with IEEE 519 tables. The standard's limits are only for the point of common coupling (PCC); values measured at the input of a single device or within a facility are not comparable to these limits (IEEE 519-2014, clause 5).

Relating to: What are Harmonics? THD, TDD, and Limit Values

The DC bus also carries traces of faults: during rapid deceleration or when the load motor is driven, energy returns to the bus, and the voltage rises; if there is no braking resistance or it is insufficient, the drive may give an overvoltage fault. Voltage dips in the mains lead to undervoltage faults. Therefore, the drive fault log and the mains event log should be read together.

Motor side: PWM voltage, dv/dt, and insulation.

At the drive output, the DC bus voltage is applied to the motor using pulse width modulation (PWM) at a switching frequency in the kilohertz range. The current appears close to a sine wave, but each side of the voltage has a very high rate of change (dv/dt).

The motor cable acts as a conduction line for these ends. Because the impedances don't match, the pulse is reflected at the motor terminals, and the peak voltage increases; the effect grows as the cable length increases and, in practice, can significantly exceed the peak DC bus voltage at the motor terminal. The stress is concentrated most in the first turns of the winding; insulation erosion from partial discharge will eventually result in a winding short circuit. Older and rewound motors are more susceptible.

For motors powered by converters, the IEC 60034-17 and IEC TS 60034-25 application guidelines are provided; manufacturer data should be consulted for strength values. The Communiqué also makes it mandatory for the motor manufacturer to provide the special precautions to be taken when the motor is used with a drive in the technical data sheet or user manual since July 1, 2022 (Annex I, Article 2(3)(ç)).

The second side effect is on the bearings. Since the sum of the phase voltages at the PWM output is not zero, a common-mode voltage is generated and transferred to the shaft capacitively. When the shaft voltage reaches a level that punctures the oil film, a discharge current flows through the bearing; over time, washboard-like marks (fluting) and increased vibration are observed on the slip ring.

Leakage current: Why does a drive trip the RCD?

In drive-driven circuits, the majority of the current that trips the residual current device (RCD) does not come from insulation faults, but from the circuit's own capacitors. The capacitors of the input EMC (electromagnetic compatibility) filter connected to ground continuously flow current at the mains frequency, while the cable and winding capacitors on the output side continuously flow current at the switching frequency; this current increases as the cable length increases. IEC 62423 also states that in a phase-to-neutral supplied frequency converter, the leakage current can consist of mains, motor, and switching frequency components (IEC 62423:2009, Introduction).

The standard defines two types for these currents. Type F is for circuits with frequency converters fed between phase and neutral; in addition to the features of Type A, it enables tripping for compound leakage currents and pulsed DC currents superimposed on smooth DC of 0.01 A (clauses 1, 3.3 and 5.1). Type F cannot be used in circuits where two-phase bridge rectifiers are present or where smooth DC leakage currents may occur (Introduction). Type B, in addition to these, enables tripping for sinusoidal AC up to 1000 Hz, two or more phase rectified (including six-pulse bridge in 3 and 4-pole devices) and polarity-independent smooth DC leakage currents (clauses 3.2 and 5.2.1).

In a three-phase drive, a DC bus or ground fault on the output side can generate a nearly uniform DC leakage current; the type defined by the standard for this current is Type B. However, IEC 62423 increases the tripping thresholds for Type B beyond the mains frequency: at 1000 Hz, the device should not trip at its rated leakage current (IΔn), but at a maximum of 14 IΔn; at 150 Hz, the range is between 0.5 IΔn and 2.4 IΔn (clause 5.2.3, Table 2). Therefore, the RCD's response to the drive cannot be predicted solely by looking at the IΔn at 50 Hz. IEC 62423 covers household and similar appliances; industrial toroidal relays are subject to different product standards.

The practical sequence is as follows: measure the leakage current and decompose it into its frequency components, distribute the drives to multiple RCDs and review the filter-cable arrangement, determine the type of RCD, the IΔn value, and the need for a delayed (S) type for selectivity; define separate durations for the standard S type (clause 5.2.2, Table 1 and clause 8.1). Bridging the RCD or replacing it with a device with a very high IΔn is not a solution.

Relating to: Industrial Type Analyses of Residual Current Devices (RCDs)

Electromagnetic compatibility obligation

Leakage current and bearing problems often begin with faulty installation from an EMC perspective. The Electromagnetic Compatibility Directive (2014/30/EU) defines the equipment as a device or fixed installation and requires it to meet the essential requirements in Annex I (Articles 5(1)(g) and 6). Information on special precautions to be taken during assembly, installation, maintenance and use is provided with the device (Article 20(1)); shielded cable, grounding and filter instructions in the drive manual are examples of this. Good engineering practices are documented in fixed installations (Article 21(1)); in case of a complaint of malfunction, the Ministry may request proof of conformity and require precautions (Article 21(2)). The product-level EMC standard for drives is IEC 61800-3.

Productivity: What does the announcement require?

The Communiqué (Article 4), based on EU Regulations 2019/1781 and 2021/341, was published on 28 April 2021, and most of its provisions entered into force on 15 August 2021 (Article 13). It covers 2, 4, 6 or 8-pole induction motors with a rated power of 0.12 kW to 1000 kW, a rated voltage above 50 V and a maximum of 1000 V, and three-phase input drives operating with these motors (Article 2(1)).

Product groupRemembrance powerMinimum levelForceRest
Three-phase motor, 2-4-6-8 poles (excluding Ex eb)0.75–1000 kWIE3August 15, 2021Annex I Article 1(1)(a)(1)
Three-phase motor, 2-4-6-8 poles (excluding Ex eb)Below 0.12 kW to 0.75 kWIE2August 15, 2021Annex I Article 1(1)(a)(2)
Ex eb enhanced safety motor, 2-4-6-8 poles0.12–1000 kWIE2July 1, 2023Annex I Article 1(1)(b)(1)
Single-phase motor0.12 kW and aboveIE2July 1, 2023Annex I Article 1(1)(b)(1)
Three-phase motor, 2-4-6 poles (excluding motors with brakes, Ex eb and other explosion-proof motors)75–200 kWIE4July 1, 2023Annex I Article 1(1)(b)(2)
Variable speed drive (operated with 0.12–1000 kW motors)—IE2 (power loss)August 15, 2021Annex I, Article 3(1)(a)

The IE (international energy efficiency class) is not the same scale for motors and drives. The motor class is determined by the minimum efficiency tables at rated power, rated voltage and a reference ambient temperature of 25 °C (Annex I, item 1(1)(c)). The drive class, on the other hand, is based on power loss: the loss is found at 90% of the motor's rated stator frequency and 100% of the rated torque production current and is compared with the reference losses in Table 6 (Annex I, item 3(1)(b), Annex II, item 3(a)).

The drive's information sheet includes losses at six speed-torque points and standby loss; the efficiency level, losses and year of manufacture are marked on or near the drive's classification plate (Annex I, Article 4(1)(b) and 4(1)(c)); similar loss information for motors has been mandatory since 1 July 2022 (Annex I, Article 2(3)(a)). This data is used to test a savings claim by calculation at partial load.

Efficiency requirements do not apply to regenerative drives, sinusoidal input current drives with a total harmonic content (THC) of the input current below 10%, and drives that are attached to a product and cannot be tested independently of it (Article 2(3), Article 5(1)(s)). There are also conditional exceptions for motors, such as those with embedded, compact drives and motors marketed with the phrase ’Motor to be used as spare parts only“ (Article 2(2), Annex I Article 2(3)(d)). The Communiqué relates to placing on the market and putting into service (Article 1); it does not impose an obligation to replace the working motor.

Relating to: IEC 60034-30-1 Motor Efficiency Classes (IE)

How is drive analysis conducted in the field?

The steps in a typical study are as follows:

  • A single-line diagram, drive list (power, input reactor or DC choke, filter), motor cable type and length, RCD placement, and drive fault logs are collected.
  • A power quality analyzer is connected to the drive input, and at least one complete production cycle is recorded. If the issue concerns a transformer or grid connection point, the recording period is extended to a week, as IEEE 519-2014 evaluates 10-minute harmonic values with weekly statistics (clauses 4.3 and 4.4).
  • On the motor side, peak voltage and dv/dt are measured at the drive output and motor terminal with a high-bandwidth oscilloscope and an insulated differential probe; power quality analyzers typically cannot detect these pulse edges.
  • Leakage current is measured in the supply cable and protective conductor using a broadband clamp meter; at energization, start-up, and at different speeds.
  • Drive terminals, DC bus connections, brake resistor, and motor terminal box are thermally scanned under load using a thermal camera.
  • In the motor, insulation resistance and polarization index (PI) are measured; vibration analysis is added if bearing problems are suspected.

Measurement on the drive panel is a job for qualified personnel. DC bus capacitors carry dangerous voltage for a period of time even after the power is cut off; the manufacturer's specified waiting time must be observed and the absence of voltage must be verified.

Typical findings and solutions

The measurement results determine which solution is needed, or even if a solution is needed at all.

FindingPossible causeSolution direction
High current harmonics at the input, transformer overheating.Reactorless six-pulse drivesInput reactor or DC choke, passive or active harmonic filter, active front-end (AFE) drive.
Capacitor failures after drive addition.Resonance between compensation and the grid.Reactor-based (detuned) compensation
Winding failure in long-cable motors.The reflected wave has a high dv/dt.Output reactor, dv/dt or sine filter, short cable, motor with appropriate insulation.
Residual current relay trippingFilter and cable capacity, multiple drives in a single RCD.Leakage current measurement, circuit division, wiring and filter arrangement, correct RCD type and selectivity.
Bearing failure, increased vibration.Mill voltage, weak high-frequency grounding.360° terminated shielded cable, equipotential bonding, shaft grounding ring, insulated bearing.
Stop due to overvoltage fault.Rapid deceleration, the load driving the motor.Ramp adjustment, brake resistor, regenerative unit, supply voltage analysis.

Relating to: Harmonic Filter Selection: Passive, Active, and Reactor-Based Solutions

When should a drive analysis be conducted?

  • If drives have repeated errors and stops
  • If winding or bearing failures recur in drive-controlled motors
  • If residual current devices trip without the cause being found
  • To test the transformer and compensation before adding a large number of drives.
  • If compensation failures started after a drive retrofit
  • If a savings claim is to be verified with before and after measurements

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does the drive trip the residual current device?

In most cases, there is no insulation fault: the EMC filter and the capacitance of the motor cable cause a continuous current to flow to ground, this current peaks during energization, and the currents of the drives in the same RCD add up. The solution is circuit design based on measurements and the correct RCD selection.

Which type of residual current device should be used in a drive-fed circuit?

It depends on the circuit. IEC 62423 defines Type F for converter-fed circuits with phase-to-neutral supply, and Type B for smooth DC and multi-phase rectifier leakage currents (clauses 3.2 and 3.3); therefore, three-phase drives are mostly evaluated as Type B in practice. The decision is made by considering the grounding system, manufacturer's manual, measurement, and selectivity together.

Why is motor cable length important?

As the cable length increases, the peak voltage at the motor terminals rises due to the reflected wave, and the leakage current increases along with the cable capacitance. The permissible length depends on the manufacturer's specifications and the filter; in case of doubt, it should be measured at the motor terminals.

Is there an efficiency requirement for variable speed drives?

Yes. The power loss of the covered drives cannot exceed the maximum loss corresponding to the IE2 level since 15 August 2021 (Notification, Annex I, article 3(1)(a)); regenerative and sinusoidal input current drives are exempt (article 2(3)). The obligation rests with the manufacturer placing the product on the market; the business must check the plate and documents of the newly acquired drive.

Sources

Relating to: Electric Motor Periodic Testing and Maintenance

Relating to: Vibration Analysis and Predictive Maintenance

Relating to: How to find an electrical fault?

Relating to: Engine Start-up Analysis

Relating to: Power Quality Measurements

If you would like to schedule measurements for the drives at your facility, please contact us. Entry-side recording takes at least one week, especially if a production cycle, transformer, or grid connection point is involved.