Short answer: A recurring electrical fault is found not by replacing parts sequentially, but by recording the symptom and ruling out possible causes with targeted measurements. Leakage current relay and circuit breaker tripping, panel overheating, and voltage problems each have a distinct measurement; intermittent events can only be detected by monitoring them over time with an event-recording device.
It's a familiar scenario: the residual current device trips a few times a week, often at night. The relay is replaced, the socket group is moved to another line, the circuit breaker is upgraded; the problem subsides for a while and then returns. Often the replaced part isn't faulty, it's just the device that reported the fault. If the protection trips, it has detected something; the real question is what it detected. Therefore, detecting intermittent faults is a matter of measurement and recording.
Method: from symptom to root cause
The cheapest data for troubleshooting is the operational personnel's log of symptoms: which protection was activated, what time was it, which machines were running, was there rain or washing, was a new load added to the facility? The steps we follow in the field are as follows:
- Record the symptom with these details.
- Eliminate possible causes from the record and determine the metric that will confirm or rule out each one.
- Perform targeted measurements: insulation resistance, loop impedance, leakage current, actual effective current, temperature.
- If the event is intermittent, connect a device that records the event and wait for the symptom to recur.
- Match the recorded event with the symptom to identify and correct the root cause.
- Repeat the same measurement and confirm that the symptom has not returned over a period encompassing its previous frequency.
Why does a residual current device trip?
A residual current device (RCD) trips the circuit when the difference between the outgoing and returning currents reaches its tripping threshold; however, the relay may trip even before reaching its rated tripping current (IΔn). This difference indicates that some of the current is returning through the protective conductor (PE) or to ground. There are five common causes.
The true insulation fault is the easiest to locate: measuring the insulation resistance by isolating the loads in a de-energized circuit reveals the faulty section. More difficult is the accumulated, continuous leakage. Computers, uninterruptible power supplies (UPS), electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) filters, and drives all draw small currents into the PE during normal operation; these accumulate in a single relay, and when they approach the threshold, a small switching pulse trips the relay. The distinguishing measurement is the record obtained with a leakage current clamp that wraps the phases and neutral together at the relay output for at least one shift; the practical solution is not to increase the size of the relay, but to divide the load across multiple relays.
The third reason is the wrong type of relay; circuits supplying drives, UPSs, or rectifier devices may contain leakage current direct current and high-frequency components. IEC 62423:2009 defines Type F as a device that, in addition to Type A, ensures tripping in combined (multi-frequency) leakage currents in frequency converter circuits supplied between phase and neutral (clauses 3.3 and 5.1). Type B, in addition, provides tripping in sinusoidal leakage current up to 1000 Hz, rectified current from two or more phases, and direct current (clauses 3.2 and 5.2.1). The standard states that Type F cannot be used in circuits where two-phase dual-bridge rectifiers are present or where direct current leakage may occur (introduction). The first check is the relay type designation (clause 6). In practice, a relay not designed for direct current may lose its sensitivity to this current; the problem is not tripping, but not tripping.
The fourth reason is that the neutral and PE conductors are combined in a junction box or device at the relay output, or that two relays share a neutral; the relay trips as the load increases, and the de-energized neutral–PE insulation measurement directly demonstrates this. The Electrical Installation Regulations also require that protective and neutral conductors not be mixed during commissioning inspections (Article 46, paragraph 1). The fifth reason is humidity: if the tripping coincides with rain, dew, or washing hours, the measurement is repeated under these conditions.
Replacing the relay with a model with a higher tripping current or removing it from the circuit is not a solution. The Electrical Installation Regulations aim for the faulty circuit to be opened within 0.2 seconds with fault current protection (Article 39, a). In TT systems, the Electrical Installations Grounding Regulations require the condition RA × Ia ≤ 50 V: RA is the total resistance of the grounding conductor and the protective conductor, Ia is the current that activates the protective device; if protection is provided by a residual current relay, Ia is the relay's rated tripping current IΔn (Article 8-a4/ii). For example, in a 300 mA relay, this condition allows a maximum of approximately 167 Ω; as the tripping current increases, the permissible grounding resistance decreases.
Relating to: What should the grounding resistance be in Ohms?
Why do circuit breakers and fuses trip?
The cause of a circuit breaker or fuse tripping is usually determined by the timing of the trip. In overload situations, tripping is delayed: the circuit opens thermally after minutes or hours, and the current record taken during the shift shows how close the load is to its rated current. In short circuits, tripping is instantaneous, and the circuit breaker trips immediately upon resetting; de-energized insulation measurement locates the faulty section, while loop impedance measurement indicates whether the protection will trip a fault quickly enough.
Trips at commissioning are usually caused by the starting current of the motor, transformer, LED lighting group, or capacitor stage (starting current in the motor, magnetization current in the transformer). This short peak is only visible with event recordings of half a period or finer resolution; the tripping curve is only replaced if the recording confirms this and the cable protection is not compromised. If the circuit breaker trips at “normal current,” harmonic heating should be considered: simple clamps measuring relative to the average value may underestimate the distorted waveform current, so the actual effective current and total harmonic distortion (THD) are measured. If the tripping occurs in a higher stage circuit breaker instead of the one closest to the fault, the problem is selectivity; the tripping curves and settings of the stages are compared.
Relating to: Overcurrent Protection and Fuse/Switch Coordination
Panel and connection overheating.
If heating is concentrated at a single terminal, the cause is usually a loose or oxidized connection; as contact resistance increases, heating feeds itself. Uniform heating along the conductor indicates an overload, while a single phase being hotter than the others indicates imbalance. Neutral heating is a separate issue: in four-wire panels supplying numerous single-phase nonlinear loads (computers, LED lighting, small drives), the third harmonic and its multiples do not cancel each other out in the neutral, but add up; in practice, the neutral current can approach or even exceed the phase current. The Electrical Internal Installations Project Preparation Regulation requires that conductor, cable, and busbar current carrying calculations in the final project be made taking harmonic currents into account (Article 10, c-1-vi). If harmonic loads were added later, the existing cross-sections may not have been selected according to this load.
Thermography makes these indications visible but only shows the surface temperature; the measurement should be done under load and similar components should be compared. In low-voltage switchgear, thermography is among the periodic inspections covered by our accreditation. However, investigating the cause of the detected hot spot by measuring current, harmonics, and load profiles is an engineering service we provide outside the scope of our accreditation.
Relating to: Temperature Measurement with a Thermographic Camera
Voltage issues: crashes, interruptions, flickering, instability
Contactor drops, low voltage faults in drives, and PLC restarts are often signs of voltage sag. EN 50160:2022+A1:2025 defines voltage sag at the supply point as the effective voltage falling below 90% of the reference voltage, lasting between 10 ms and 1 minute (clauses 3.3.9 and 3.3.10). If the voltage falls below 5% of the reference, it is considered a supply interruption; interruptions lasting up to 3 minutes are considered short, and longer interruptions are considered long, and in a multi-phase system, all phases must fall below this threshold for an interruption (clause 3.1.10). Standard failures are now classified by voltage (90–80%, 80–70%, 70–40%, 40–5% and below 5%) and duration (10–200 ms, 200–500 ms, 0.5–1 s, 1–5 s, 5–60 s) bands (item 4.3.2.4, Table 2).
The critical question is whether the failure originated from the grid or internally; the standard also indicates faults in the grid and user installations as typical sources of failures (clause 4.3.2.1). In practice, simultaneous recording is taken at the main input and the affected panel: if the current in the installation increases significantly at the moment of failure, the cause is most likely internally; if the voltage drops without an increase in current, it is mostly on the grid side. EN 50160 provides for the EN 61000-4-30 method in failure statistics (clause 4.3.2.2).
The flickering of lights is a type of flickering and is measured by the intensity of short and long-term flickering (Pst, Plt); EN 50160 stipulates that the Plt value should not exceed 1 for 95% of the time in a week (clause 4.2.3.2). Voltage imbalance may be behind motor heating and drive errors; according to the standard, the negative component should remain within the range of 0–2% of the positive component for 95% of the 10-minute values in a week (clause 4.2.4). The collective burning of single-phase devices is usually a sign of a loose or broken neutral: the star point shifts, devices in the lightly loaded phase may see voltages approaching the phase-to-phase voltage; the separation of phase-neutral voltages and the load-varying neutral-protective conductor (N–PE) voltage indicate this.
Slow deterioration of insulation.
Some failures develop over the years: cable and winding insulation age due to heat, humidity, and contamination, eventually causing the protection to fail. A single measurement tells little; a consistent decrease in measurements over the years, under the same test voltage and similar conditions, provides an opportunity for intervention before a failure occurs. In motors, the polarization index shows the effect of humidity and contamination in the winding better than a single instantaneous value.
Relating to: What should the Megger resistance be in MΩ?
Compensation-related failures
Frequent blown capacitor fuses, swollen capacitors, or increased voltage disturbance when switching stages are often signs of resonance or harmonic overload: capacitors create a resonance with the system inductance, and harmonics at this frequency increase. The Electrical Internal Installations Project Preparation Regulation requires the calculation of the total load current, the calculation of the resonance frequency, and the determination of the reactor/capacitor ratio for harmonic loads in the compensation project (Article 10, c-4-ii and iii). Harmonics are recorded when switching stages on one by one during fault detection. Reactor compensation or filters are recommended only if this recording indicates a need; otherwise, they are not necessary.
Symptom list
| Symptom | Possible causes | Discriminant measurement | Vehicle |
|---|---|---|---|
| The residual current device trips independently of the load. | Constant leaks, dampness, insulation failures. | Temporary leakage current record; de-energized insulation resistance | Leakage current pliers, insulation meter |
| The residual current device trips as the load increases. | Neutral–PE contact, common neutral | De-energized neutral – PE insulation measurement | Insulation gauge |
| The relay in the drive/UPS circuit is tripping or not opening during testing. | Inappropriate relay type | Type marking; tripping current and duration test. | RCD test device, analyzer |
| The circuit breaker trips with a delay. | Overload, harmonic heating | Real effective current and harmonic recording. | Power quality analyzer |
| The circuit breaker trips during activation. | Starting current, unsuitable curve. | Half-period resolution event log | Event recording analyzer |
| The circuit breaker trips instantly, it doesn't reset. | Short circuit | De-energized insulation resistance; loop impedance | Insulation and loop impedance meter |
| Terminal block or neutral wire | Loose coupling, third harmonics and their multiples, imbalance. | Comparative thermography under load; neutral and phase currents. | Thermal camera, analyzer |
| Contactors drop out, drives trip on faults | Voltage drop, brief interruption. | Simultaneous event logging on the login and dashboard. | Event recording analyzer |
| Single-phase devices are burning out. | Loose or detached neutral | Phase-neutral and N–PE voltages | Analyzer |
| Capacitor fuses are blowing frequently. | Resonance, harmonic overload | Harmonic recording when entering the stages | Analyzer |
Legal framework: periodic inspection
According to Annex III of the Regulation on Health and Safety Conditions in the Use of Work Equipment, updated on 23.12.2025, periodic inspections of installations are carried out annually unless otherwise specified in the relevant standards (Annex III, 2.3.1). For electrical and grounding installations, the maximum period is 1 year if no period is specified in the standard (Annex III, Table 3). Inspections are carried out by authorized electrical engineers and other professionals listed in the regulation (Annex III, 2.3.2). The regulation also stipulates periodic inspections after major maintenance and repairs (Article 7, second paragraph, a-2); this provision should be kept in mind during comprehensive repairs following a malfunction.
Security
In energized installations, measurements are only carried out by authorized and trained personnel using appropriate equipment and personal protective equipment at the measurement point. In de-energized measurements, the circuit is disconnected, locked and tagged (LOTO: lockout-tagout), and the absence of voltage is verified by measurement. The Electrical Internal Installations Regulation also requires appropriate measuring devices and protective measures to prevent accidents or fires during protection inspection measurements (Article 46, paragraph 3).
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does a residual current device trip for no reason?
A relay doesn't trip without a reason; it has exceeded the detected leakage current threshold. The cause is often accumulated continuous leakage, moisture, neutral-PE contact at the relay output, or an unsuitable relay type; continuous leakage current recording and de-energized insulation measurement can differentiate these.
Why does the circuit breaker get hot?
The most common cause is a loose or oxidized connection; followed by overload and harmonic current. The actual effective current is measured under load using thermography: if heating is concentrated in a single terminal, the connection is investigated; if it is uniform across all poles, the load or harmonics are investigated.
Is it necessary to shut down the facility to diagnose the problem?
Most of the time, no. Leakage current, harmonic, and event logs are taken while the facility is running; the way to catch intermittent faults is to monitor normal operation. For de-energized measurements such as insulation resistance, only the relevant circuit is isolated, locked, and labeled during a planned shutdown.
How are intermittent faults detected?
By recording over a period covering the frequency of symptom recurrence. For an event occurring once a week, at least one week of recording is required; EN 50160 also assesses continuous magnitudes on a weekly basis (e.g., clause 4.2.4). The timestamps of the recording are matched with the staff's symptom record.
Are periodic inspections and fault diagnosis the same thing?
No. Periodic inspection is a legal obligation that assesses the condition of a facility at a specific point in time according to defined criteria. Fault detection, on the other hand, searches for the root cause of a specific problem through hypothesis and time-based recording; therefore, the occurrence of intermittent failures in a facility that has undergone periodic inspection is not contradictory; the two processes complement each other.
Sources
- Regulation on Health and Safety Requirements in the Use of Work Equipment, Periodic inspection obligation and Annex III — Official Gazette 25.04.2013, number 28628
- Regulation Amending the Regulation on Health and Safety Requirements in the Use of Work Equipment, New text of Article 7 and Annex III — Official Gazette 23.12.2025, number 33116
- Electrical Installation Regulations, Indirect contact protection, fault current protection connection and inspection of protection devices — Official Gazette 04.11.1984, number 18565
- Regulations on Grounding in Electrical Installations, Article 8 (Condition RA × Ia ≤ 50 V in TT systems) — Official Gazette, August 21, 2001, No. 24500
- Regulation on the Preparation of Electrical Interior Installation Projects, Harmonic currents and compensation project calculations — Official Gazette 03.12.2003, number 25305
- IEC 62423:2009 (European edition EN 62423:2012+A12:2022), Type F and Type B residual current protection devices with and without surge protection for household and similar uses.
- EN 50160:2022+A1:2025, Voltage characteristics of electricity supplied by general electricity grids.
Relating to: What is Energy Analysis and How is it Performed?
Relating to: Motor Drive (VFD) Analysis
Relating to: Reactive Energy Penalty and Compensation
Relating to: Residual Current Device (RCD) Tests
Relating to: Electric Motor Periodic Testing and Maintenance
If you would like to schedule measurements at your facility to find the root cause of a recurring fault, please contact us. The recording period depends on how frequently the symptom recurs; during our initial consultation, we will review your existing symptom record together and determine the measurement points and duration.